Barnsley 1-2 Blues: “A Proper Team”

This win against Barnsley was our most uncharacteristic 3 points of the season so far but it’s the sort of win that promoted sides get throughout a campaign.

This win against Barnsley was our most uncharacteristic 3 points of the season so far. But it’s the sort of win that promoted sides get throughout a campaign.

Just a few days earlier, the club posted a video on social media from the dressing room following our 2-0 victory against Stockport. In that game, Blues had to do a lot of defending and play direct in the second half as Stockport pressed high successfully and chased a way back into the game. Davies addressed the players post match, and part of his message was about doing the physical part of the game to become “a proper team”. I’ll slightly paraphrase and censor his speech below:

“Defensively, the spirit, the heart, the fight, bouncing balls I said they’ve got to be a blue head, a blue foot and it was. So we’re showing we’re a proper team now, we play football, but we’re there for the fight as well. And that’s going to be the difference for us from being here [mimes at head] to being the team we want to be [mimes above head].”

In the strong winds and rain of Storm Darragh away to Barnsley, a direct and physical team, we had to show that element of our game again and fight to come from behind to get the victory.

Adversity came early, with Alex Cochrane picking up a nasty looking injury within 5 minutes after being on the receiving end of a rough tackle. Cochrane was stretchered off and looked in good spirits as he applauded the serenading 5,000 travelling Bluenoses. We all hope his injury isn’t too serious as he has been one of our best players this season. However, this left Blues in a predicament without Lee Buchanan back to full fitness, we had no other natural left backs on the bench. Ethan Laird shifted across to the left to cover, and Taylor Gardner-Hickman came off the bench to take up Laird’s vacated role.

The game had few chances overall, conditions playing a factor for both sides, but Blues struggled to get into our usual rhythm throughout the game. Blues had adopted a more structured 3 at the back shape, rather than the hybrid 4 at the back we’ve seen throughout the season, presumably to match up with Barnsley’s. The first half was very even and resulted in minimal moments of excitement.

Stansfield found himself in behind the defence on the halfway line, and was looking to get a shot away before Barnsley’s Georgie Gent recovered well and put a strong tackle in to deny a shooting chance. Laird found himself in the 6 yard box on the end of a May cross, but couldn’t get enough power or direction on his header to fire past the goalkeeper.

Barnsley had a penalty shout waved away by the referee for a challenge on Humphrys by Bielik. Darrell Clarke was booked for his protests from the Barnsley dugout. And on the stroke of half time, Adam Phillips took aim from the edge of the box but Allsop parried away comfortably.

Half time: Barnsley 0-0 Blues

The second half opened up a bit more. Davies recognised the battle the game was turning out to be, and replaced Luke Harris (who had picked up a booking for a late tackle) for Lukas Jutkiewicz, who helped to provide an out-ball throughout the remainder of the match.

Barnsley came out from half time on fire, and fashioned themselves a decent chance less than a minute into the half, picking up a loose ball in midfield and exploiting space in the Blues back line, but Bielik came back in time to block Keillor-Dunn’s effort from a tight angle.

A few minutes later, Marc Roberts picked up a cleared ball from a Barnsley corner and dinked a cross into the Blues box towards Jonathan Russell, who’s header was cleared off the line in sensational fashion by Paik Seung-ho. Paik had to run back towards his goal and acrobatically twist his body and neck from a tough angle, but kept the ball out and saved us from the opening goal.

O’Keefe took a shot straight at Allsop, who almost fumbled into his own net before recovering and securing the ball.

Barnsley broke on the counter shortly after, and Humphrys turned Davies inside and out before firing across goal, and Paik couldn’t get out of the way before tapping the ball into his own net to put the Reds ahead.

It would be difficult to argue against Barnsley deserving their goal after how they’d started the second half, and it felt like a tough game that might result in a 1-0 victory for the hosts, with Blues not looking likely to score.

But then less than a minute after kick-off, with Barnsley still celebrating, May picked up a loose ball and laid it off to Stansfield, who wriggled his way past two Barnsley defenders and struck a scorcher from 25 yards and equalised right in front of the travelling support. Jay was the only player on the pitch with the quality to score a goal like that, and deliver a sucker-punch immediately to a Barnsley side who worked hard to get their noses ahead.

Marc Leonard got his game time and was called upon to try and gain control of the match just after the equaliser, and the game became even once more. Barnsley had flew into challenges all afternoon, injuring Cochrane and picking up several yellow cards in the process. The same player who had made that tackle in the opening minutes, scythed down Laird on the 70th and received his second booking of the game and his marching orders with it. Phillips seemed incensed at his teammate who allowed Laird to pick up the ball from his loose touch, and completed his walk of shame past 5,000 waving arms and chants of “Cheerio” from the away end.

Blues for the first time gained control of the match, helped by the man advantage and a 3 man midfield of Iwata, Paik and Leonard. It was the South Korean international who would deliver the corner that evaded everyone in the middle, and it was Stansfield who fought his way past Gent, who denied his 1-on-1 in the first half, to nod home from inside the 6 yard box and put Blues ahead on the 79th minute.

Barnsley tried to respond, but Blues defended diligently and whittled the clock down in a game we didn’t exert our usual control upon, and came away with the 3 points. Not trademark Blues of 2024/25. But a gutsy, battling performance which Davies praised mere days before, resulted in another big 3 points on the road and our 3rd consecutive victory in the league.

Blues travel away again to Exeter in the newly re-branded Vertu Trophy (previously Bristol Street Motors) for our first knockout round on Tuesday, and return home in the league to host Bristol Rovers on Saturday, bang in form and winning games in different ways – the sign of a very good team.

Full time: Barnsley 1-2 Blues (Stansfield x2)

Ratings

Starting XI

Ryan Allsop: 6

Ryan saved the couple of shots on target he faced throughout the match, played well with the ball at his feet and couldn't be faulted for the Barnsley goal.

Ethan Laird: 7

Ethan returned to the starting line-up following Keshi Anderson's suspension, but had to play almost the entire game on the left hand side after Cochrane's injury. Playing out of position, I'm happy to give Laird some lee-way. I felt he should've done better with his header in the first half, and he misplaced a pass in the box earlier on which should've found May in a decent shooting position. However, his overall game was good, he defended well and kept his concentration for the most part, as well as making the run which forced a tackle that reduced Barnsley to 10.

Krystian Bielik: 7

Bielik and the other 2 centre backs had a job on their hands, with high levels of concentration required in the windy conditions and direct style of Barnsley. He handled it well - although was involved in a contentious moment with Humphrys that another referee might've given as a penalty.

Christoph Klarer: 7

Klarer's new-found central role in the Blues back 3 means he cannot venture up the pitch like we've seen him do this season, but he executed the defensive side of his game well and stood up to the challenge.

Ben Davies: 6

Davies makes Blues look more competent in defence, and the stats back that up with 5 clean sheets in 8 games started, only conceding 4 goals when he's been on the pitch. He did however get turned inside and out for the Barnsley goal.

Alex Cochrane: 6

Cochrane was withdrawn due to injury 5 minutes into the match. I wish him all the best in what is hopefully a swift recovery, as he will be a big miss while he's out.

Paik Seung-Ho: 8

Paik, on the surface of it, had a mixed bag of a game - but generally dealt very well with the conditions and physicality. He made an excellent clearance off the line, then scored an own goal (that he couldn't do much about, in fairness) and then whipped in a great corner for our winning goal.

Tomoki Iwata: 6

Tomoki struggled, and didn't exert his usual control of the game in possession. But he did protect the backline well, and matched up to the physical challenge of the game.

Luke Harris: 5

I really want to like Luke Harris, and I want to give him time as a young lad, but he's not doing it for me at the moment, and his half-time withdrawal after receiving a booking shows Davies probably agrees, at least in the context of this game. Could argue the conditions weren't suited to him, but he didn't put on a good display.

Jay Stansfield: 9 - Man of the Match

When we needed a hero to drag us through, Stanno delivered. He looked lively all game, his first goal was absolutely top class, and his second he had great anticipation and fight to get onto the end of the corner. Easy man of the match - showing the football world why we signed him, and why we love him.

Alfie May: 6

It wasn't to be for Alfie today, after scoring twice in midweek. He worked his legs off as he always does, and did set the ball for Stansfield to score his first, but you wouldn't credit the assist as much as the work Stansfield had to do to score. He'll get his chance in another game and I'm sure he'll put it away.

Subs

Taylor Gardner-Hickman: 6

TGH could be almost considered as a starter after playing over 90 minutes total, coming on for Alex Cochrane after 5 minutes. He did a solid job defensively, but it wasn't his best game and he didn't contribute much in an attacking sense that his right wing-back role would usually require.

Lukas Jutkiewicz: 7

The Juke found himself on the bench after Dykes fell ill, and came on at half time for Luke Harris. His physical presence provided Blues with a necessary outlet up front in a direct game, and he played his role admirably.

Marc Leonard: 7

Leonard finally got the gametime I've been asking for him to get for weeks, coming on in the 60th minute for Alfie May. He helped Blues massively in exerting a level of control on the game after our equaliser, and has put his argument across for a start against Exeter on Tuesday night.
To top